Many users find Apple’s iCloud storage policies unsatisfactory for several reasons. Recently, a judge ruled that some aspects of these policies could be considered monopolistic, as Apple’s attempt to dismiss an iCloud storage-related lawsuit has been rejected. Here’s what this ruling entails.
California Moves Forward with iCloud Storage Lawsuit Against Apple
According to Mike Scarcella at Reuters:
A federal judge in California has ruled that Apple must face a proposed class action that accuses the tech giant of unlawful monopolization of the digital storage market, which has resulted in consumers overpaying for iCloud services.
U.S. District Judge Eumi Lee, based in San Jose, clarified that the plaintiffs had adequately argued that Apple violated antitrust regulations by mandating iPhone users to utilize its iCloud for backing up essential data and device settings.
The full ruling from the US judge can be found here.
Apple’s iCloud storage model has been met with widespread disapproval, particularly the limitation of just 5GB of free storage, which is often criticized.
Although this lawsuit does not directly target that specific policy, it certainly has relevant implications.
The individual who initiated the lawsuit was paying $2.99 per month for iCloud storage at the time of the filing, yet raised concerns regarding the limitation that prevents third-party cloud services from being used for critical iPhone functions, such as backups.
While iOS does allow third-party apps for saving certain data types like images and videos, only iCloud supports backing up vital settings data.
Reuters highlights the significant scope of this class action: “The plaintiff’s legal team aims to represent a nationwide class encompassing tens of millions of consumers who purchased iCloud storage plans.”
If Apple loses this case and has to adjust its iCloud storage practices, the existing 5GB free limit might become more manageable or change entirely to mitigate the risk of amplified competition.
What are your thoughts on the allegations in the iCloud storage lawsuit? Share your opinions in the comments.
